Comparing confucius and aristotle on virtue coursebb. Van norden 2008, 14 consequently, mencius stresses that it is the. Confucianism exerted an influence on many countries neighboring china such as korea and japan. He provides a starting point for understanding how to live a good life. From the jacket the chinese people and several other people of east asia and south east asia have had the privilege of having grown in the shadow of confucian thought. The one question brought forth by lagan 2006 is the conflict between harmony in the business environment and the competition of capitalistic markets in the ethical debate on the efficacy of confucian business ethics. Virtue ethics, confucian moral teachings, wesleyan spirituality. Bryan w van norden, vassar college, philosophy department, faculty member. Their holy book is called the analects they study this book and tells them what. This virtue is the culmination of all virtues and includes moral excellence, love, and all virtues at their highest possible attainment. How are the virtue ethics of aristotle and confucius. Van norden examines early confucianism as a form of virtue ethics and mohism, an anticonfucian movement, as a version of consequentialism.
His status evolved greatly over the succeeding 1500 years, as cultural and political changes swept china, but the canon established then has endured. Philosophers aristotle and confucius are both famous persons in the worlds history. Stressed the importance of meditation and dedication to becoming a noble person. Essay about confucius and aristotle on virtue 953 words. Confucianism has been followed by the chinese for more than two millennia. Some address problematic issues in virtue ethics by using confucian resources e. All told, the papers approach the central topic of virtue ethics and confucianism from diverse angles. Variously described as tradition, a philosophy, a religion, a humanistic or rationalistic religion, a way of governing, or simply a way of life, confucianism developed from what was later called the hundred schools of thought from the teachings of the chinese philosopher confucius 551479 bce. Ethics confucianism and aristotle virtues flashcards quizlet. Ren is the highest virtue or ideal in confucianism. The hope is that couching the confucian tradition in the structure of western virtue ethics will allow a beginning.
Subjects would willingly follow a ruler with virtue, without the need for coercion. And, i think, confucius is more open to situational considerations that might warrant apparent contradiction of universal principles that is why it is closer to virtue ethics. Based on recent advances in englishlanguage scholarship on and translation of confucian philosophy, the book demonstrates that crosstradition stimulus, challenge, and. Aristotle was a great greek philosopher and scientist while confucius was a chinese politician, a philosopher and a teacher. Van norden examines early confucianism as a form of virtue ethics and mohism, an anti confucian movement, as a version of consequentialism. Bryan van norden virtue ethics and consequentialism in early chinese philosophy 2007. Confucius, a title meaning master, wrote in the fifth century b. A key point of the doctrine of the mean is the importance of a unified purpose between principle and mind, whereby one might achieve, within oneself, a manifestation of heaven. Studies chinese philosophy, chinese studies, and chinese language and. Bibliography includes bibliographical references pages 246259 and index. A classical confucian contribution to contemporary ethical reflection, journal of religious ethics 23 1995. Van norden lambastes academic philosophy for its eurocentrism and insularity and. The situationist critique and early confucian virtue ethics.
Virtue ethics and confucianism in searchworks catalog. A collection of handselected books on confucianism, chosen on the basis of apparent usefulness and quality. Mencius interpretation of confucianism has generally been considered the orthodox version by subsequent chinese philosophers, especially the neoconfucians of the song dynasty. Explain virtue base on confucianism like buddhism and taoism, confucianism does not teach the worship of a god or gods. Virtue ethics, confucian moral teachings, wesleyan. Virtue ethics somewhat mysteriously disappeared from academic circles after the 6th and final and substantially revised edition of smiths own favorite of his two published books, the theory of moral sentiments 1759, 1790. The book will be widely read by ethicists and comparative philosophers. They both made significant contributions in the worlds virtues and ethics. Adam smith, the last of the former virtue ethicists.
Nichomachean ethics by aristotle sort of the holy grail of ve, a mustread and it subsumed aristotles original ethics. Virtue ethics and the chinese confucian tradition panel 3 9. Confucianism, also known as ruism, is a system of thought and behavior originating in ancient china. One of the chief tenets of confucianism was the idea that nobility of virtue was greater than nobility of birth. All are available for purchase on click book images for details. Aaron stalnaker, coauthor of religious ethics in a time of globalism. This paper develops ideas about confucianism in business ethics. Van norden also makes a clear and strong justification for his use of virtue ethics in interpreting ruism confucianism. His text, the analects, is a record of his teachings, mostly written down by his many disciples. Debating the scope and applicability of virtue and virtue ethics 1.
His books include virtue ethics and consequentialism in early chinese. Buy virtue ethics and confucianism by stephen angle isbn. There are thousands of classic textbooks of confucianism, none of them being holy. In the western traditions, especially in the writings of aristotle, the basic theoretical components of virtue ethics are more explicitly outlined. While confucius was born in china and spearheaded a new way of perceiving morality, aristotle was born in macedongreece and also immersed his. Variously described as tradition, a philosophy, a religion, a humanistic or rationalistic religion, a way of governing, or simply a way of life, confucianism developed from what was later called the hundred schools of thought from the teachings of the chinese philosopher. Over the course of centuries, confucianism became the dominant system of thought in china, surpassing competing systems such as taoism. This paper develops ideas about confucianism in business ethics by extending discussion. Ivanhoe virtue ethics and the chinese confucian tradition 1. Still a fledgling in chinese and comparative philosophy justin tiwald the past couple of decades have witnessed a remarkable burst. The secular as sacred religious traditions of the world. The emotion of shame and the virtue of righteousness in mencius. Virtue ethics and consequentialism in early chinese.
Compare confucianism emphasis on duties and not rights no straightforward applicable rules ritual propriety similar to etiquette and politics are of a piece with ethics socialmoral structure, hierarchy, and harmony are important is confucianism more like deontology, consequentialism, virtue ethics, or its. Early confucianism has explicit strategies for strengthening and expanding character traits over. Confucianism has attracted some attention in business ethics, in particular as a form of virtue ethics. Confucianism is, then, a more focused virtue ethics. Surprisingly, this volume is the first and only anthology on these topics in english. Those who do not work in the combination of chinese philosophy and ethics may wonder what all of the fuss is about. Nonetheless, how to understand both figure and text is constantly under dispute. Chapter iii confucian ethics and the limits of rights theory if, in serving his parents, he can exert his utmost strength. In this lavishly illustrated volume, jennifer oldstonemoore takes readers on an insightful tour of this. Confucius is one of the most influential figuresas historical individual and as symbolin world history. Van norden, virtue ethics and consequentialism in early. Confucianism and contemporary virtue ethics, codirected by stephen angle and michael slote and held at the mansfield freeman center for east asian studies on the campus of wesleyan university. Welcome to the home page for a 2008 neh summer seminar for college and university teachers, traditions into dialogue. Religionfacts does not necessarily endorse the contents of these books.
Lee context the context of this paper is hong kong taken to be a window through which to view a predominantly chinesepeopled world,1 including mainland china and taiwan, in a changing asian setting. Virtue ethics and consequentialism in early chinese philosophy. Sometimes viewed as a philosophy, sometimes as a religion, confucianism is perhaps best understood as an allencompassing humanism that neither denies nor slights heaven. Western and eastern virtue ethics in consumer research. Confucius ethics, culture and politics exotic india. Tan, sorhoon van norden, bryan toward a synthesis of confucianism and aristotelianism wong, waiying confucianism and virtue ethics revisited sim, may confucian liberties break panel 4 10. Van norden reports of the incident that precipitated the change of career.
Coleman the recent resurgence of interest in confucius and confucianism has been reflected in an outpouring of books. Their holy book is called the analects they study this book and tells them what happened in the past. Van norden, introduction to classical chinese philosophy. This volume presents the fruits of an extended dialogue among american and chinese philosophers concerning the relations between virtue ethics and the confucian tradition. Since 1790 most ethical theory as practiced in departments of philosophy has derived instead from two other books. Support of confucian business ethics in harmony of the business environment 160issue. Chapter iii confucian ethics and the limits of rights theory. Analects from the framework offered by the theoretical elements of virtue ethics. Confucius analyzed the malaise from which chinese society suffered and proceeded. Confucius, however, goes a step further than aristotle, and helps escape the potential circularity of virtue ethics. Ethics confucianism and aristotle virtues flashcards. The family is central to confucian ethics in at least two ways.
Van norden s virtue ethics and con sequentialism in early chinese philosophy, jiyuan yus the ethics of confucius. The received text of the mengzi is divided into seven books, each of which is. Virtue ethics and confucianism 1st edition stephen. Early confucianism wasnt well known premised on the idea that buddhism and daoism brought moral and political weakness into chinese society more strict education based on. An online book about this author is available, as is a wikipedia article confucius. The philosophical methodology is analytic, in that the emphasis is on clear exegesis of the texts and a critical examination of the philosophical arguments proposed by each side. Even for the nonspecialist, confucian political ethics is a lively and easily ingested read. Van nordens argument that confucianism is a form of virtue ethics. He understands virtue ethics as comprising four components. Jun 18, 2009 comments on bryan van norden s virtue ethics and consequentialism in early chinese philosophy michael slote 1 dao volume 8, pages 289 295 2009 cite this article. Virtue ethics and confucianism 1st edition stephen angle. Virtue ethics and confucianism ebook by 97814068180.
Six centuries before the birth of jesus, a chinese sage named master kong or kong fuzi later latinized to confucius drafted the principles of a society founded upon virtue. Confucianism but notice the difference between the virtues of mencius and xun zi within that same school of thought for a brief, but more comprehensive than mine, overview check out the always useful stanford encyclopedia. Van norden examines early confucianism as a form of virtue ethics. Van norden s virtue ethics and consequentialism in early chinese philosophy van norden 2007, jiyuan yus the ethics of confucius and aristotle yu 2007, and may sims remastering morals with aristotle and confucius sim 2007, for example, are representative of this popular trend. Confucianism confucianism is a way of life taught by confucius in the 6th5th century bc. Confucianism, kant, and virtue ethics virtue ethics and. Review, synthesis, and directions for future research. The ethics of confucian business ethics 1172 words 5 pages. Zhu placed this text last among the four books because, having studied the other three, the student could here study the intricacies of confucian philosophy. New essays and millions of other books are available for.
For more than two thousand years, kong fuzis work has remained the foundation of chinese civilization. Confucianism, kant, and virtue ethics in recent years, a trend of adopting the western concept of virtue ethics to interpret confucian ethics has emerged and gained popularity in the englishspeaking world. This paper argues confucianism is a compelling managerial ethic for several reasons. Confucian books are boring if youre interested in holy stories, spiritual miracles, and afterlife thrills. Bryan van norden virtue ethics and consequentialism in. Mencius also spelled mengzi or mengtzu, a book of his conversations with kings of the time, is one of the four books which form the core of orthodox confucian thinking. Their philosophic works were similar in nature, but with some different. In recent years, gilbert harman 199899, 19992000 and john doris 2002 have pointed to the influence of situations over attitude and behavior as a problem for virtue ethics. Van norden shows that confucianism, while similar to. The present and confucianism 2947 the spirit of confucianism, debate was there confucianism. This article argues that strong versions of the situationist critique of virtue ethics are empirically and conceptually unfounded, as well as that, even if one accepts that the predictive power of character may be limited, this is not a fatal problem for early confucian virtue ethics. Confucius and aristotle on virtue philosophers aristotle and confucius are both famous persons in the worlds history.
881 691 1097 1285 426 1242 282 1349 350 663 442 1532 55 158 397 1694 1091 1519 242 96 1280 1555 996 1566 732 1365 1079 605 416 1620 1427 13 1607 1482 448 666 374 406 903 173 335 766 1232 1382